DO FRENCH NOIRS TREND TOWARD "MELO"?

We are getting enough data in the Noir-o-Meter to take a look at this question. And we can do so using the same method we've been using to examine the "spectrum" of film noir (in our previous posts, which do not include the French noirs graphed in the chart below).

The "revisionist" camp (which has to be extremely precise in identifying exactly what it is revising, as there are so many "revisionists" out there...) has one wing which wonders about the hard-boiled, while also (usually to a lesser extent) turning a skeptical eye to the claims of "American exceptionalism" when it comes to film noir.

What if we discovered that the earliest manifestation of film noir, which is (arguably) the French--who begin in the early 30s, as expatriated directors with various flavors of "dark cinema" in their previous work make their way through France and influence the "local talent"--what if we found that these earliest manifestations of noir were by and large much less "hardboiled" in nature? What would that say about the "American brand"? Would we start to see it as something that was influenced by historical and aesthetic conditions unique to it and that it might at last be seen as a kind of aberration to what developed previously and elsewhere?

It's entirely possible that such might need to be the case...at least, the preliminary results from our mapping of "tough vs. tender" as it applies to French noir is concerned. (For this to be fully mapped, of course, we'll need to go past the 60 or so noirs in this initial mapping--we'll need to create the Noir-o-Meter data for all 507 French noirs that we've unearthed to date.)

But the chart below, using the same approach ("Hardboiled vs. melodrama character element ratio mapped against the overall MELO RATE") shows us that French noir looks a lot more like that subset of American noir with high scores in character triangulation--the ones we've taken to calling "melo-noirs." Take a look:

Note that the distribution across the chart is a great deal tighter than what we saw in the American sample. "Hardboiled-to-melo" character element ratios with high "hardboiled" scores are less frequent and not nearly so extreme here, in the French noir universe.

Now there are many, many more French noirs to add to the database, including a number of the "poetic realist" films (which turn out to be just one of three major sub-types of film noir that developed in France during the 1930s). So we can't be totally sure that this distribution is totally accurate...but it's an intriguing indicator of some potentially game-changing perceptions about film noir. Stay tuned!