PINPOINTING TYPES OF FEMALE CHARACTERS IN THE "TOUGH-TENDER" CONTINUUM

Extremely interesting research opportunities will continue to arise from the use of the Noir-o-Meter™ to examine the narrative and tonal range in film noir. We've been showing some examples of that in a series of posts here, including the most recent one which broke out the "hard-boiled" vs. "melo" orientation of the films being screened in the upcoming Noir City LA series (April 13-22).

Dan Hodges, a leading proponent for the revised examination of the narrative interrelationships in film noir (most notably in his trenchant, polemical "Against the Hard-Boiled Paradigm"), has engaged with a portion of the "noir elements" approach. Responding to the most recent blog entry here via its incorporation at the Blackboard, Dan notes the ratio of "women in distress" (WID) vs. "femmes fatales" (FF) in the upcoming Noir City series, showing that even the small sample size (19 films) produces a result that tends to confirm his claim that "femmes fatales," along with "hard-boiled detectives" are much more of a minority presence in films noir.

We're not at all surprised to see this, of course, and it would be interesting for Dan to apply his breakouts of WID and FF to the greater subset of films noirs shown at Noir City SF, where we anticipate similar results.

Here, however, our most useful followup exercise is to follow Dan's initial statement in his post, where he suggests a possible typological correlation between the type of female characters prominent in individual films noir (WID or FF) and the subtype of those noirs themselves (as measured by our "tough-tender index" and displayed in our recent charts).

We do this by adding a color code to those films in the NC series where Dan has identified the presence of WIDs and FFs. The question is whether the films, once identified in this fashion, will conform to the "spatial location" in the chart (a pictorial representation of a kind of "noir narrative continuum") with respect to the "hard-boiled" and "melodrama" regions we see depicted there.

When we do this, we do see such a tacit correlation, albeit with some overlap, as the color-coded version of the chart indicates:

Color key for the chart is as follows: green for Femme Fatale (FF); red for Woman in Distress (WID); purple for Homme Fatale (HF); black for the presence of both FF and WID in the same film.

Our "Homme Fatale" film from NC LA 2018 (in the upper portion of the top right quadrant on the chart) is He Walked By Night, a police procedural that portrays the most ruthless of criminals via one of noir's most chilling performances (from Richard Basehart). The more purely criminal a character is, and the less interaction with either society or the opposite sex, the more purely "hard-boiled" a noir is likely to be.

Approaching the other end of the scale (the black data point furthest to the right in the the lower right quadrant) is the film that Dan identified as being one of roughly two dozen noirs that have both FFs and WIDs present in the story. This film is Jealousy, a rare B-film from emigré director Gustav Machaty that depicts a shifting, complicated quadrangle of characters who form a series of mutating triangular relationships. (And remember that we identified the "degree of triangulation" noir element as a means by which the sub-types of noir are separated from one another: the more triangulation of characters, the more likely the noir is "melo"; conversely, the least amount of emphasis on triangulation is present, the more likely the film is "hard-boiled.)

In the in-between, we're not surprised to see some overlap in films with WIDs or FFs, because the noir elements overlap in many differing combinations and these impulses are capable of mixing. However, note that we do see a distinct visual trend even amidst the presence of an overlap--the WIDs, even in this small sample, do move toward the "melo" region, while the FF's move toward the "hard-boiled" region.

Using larger data samples, of course, is the next step for such a visualization effort. We're highly confident that this trend will be confirmed once that's undertaken. We are also asking Dan to supply his list of the films where both WIDs and FFs are present, so that we might map their location on such a chart. Our current theory is that the greater presence of women--even those of such competing "types" as FFs and WIDs--is likely to create a sub-class of "melo-noirs" that are more focused on female psychology in a world where so much is stacked against them.

Once we have Dan's list, we can test this theory, and report the actual results. Stay tuned!